[FE] Convert specific diagnostic for actual function with default arguments into a common incompatibility

^KT-59665 Fixed
Review: https://jetbrains.team/p/kt/reviews/11039/timeline

It's better to have this logic in common place
(AbstractExpectActualCompatibilityChecker) to avoid missing compilation
errors in the future

This commit fixes:
1. Missing compilation error for actual function with default arguments
   for 'actual typealias' KT-59665
2. Missing compilation error for actual function with default arguments
   for actual fake-override KT-59665

Alternative solution for KT-59665 is to create a special checker.

"incompatibility" vs "special checker":

Arguments for common incompatibility:
- What if we had a rule that expect and actual default params must
  match? If so then it certainly would be an incompatibility.
- Technically, we do the matching of expect and actual params (because
  we allow default params in common ancestors of expect and actual
  declarations).
- It's hard to check that the actual definition doesn't use default
  params because `ExpectedActualResolver.findActualForExpected` filters
  out fake-overrides and doesn't return them. It's not clear logic for
  me, that I'm afraid to touch.
  implicitActualFakeOverride_AbstractMap.kt test breaks if you drop this
  weird logic
- WEAK incompatibilities can be considered as "checkers". So it doesn't
  matter how it's implemented, as a "incompatibility" or a "checker"

Arguments against common incompatibility:
- Although we match expect and actual declarations to allow default
  params in common ancestors of expect and actual declarations, it's
  still can be considered that we check that the actual declaration
  doesn't have default params. And it doesn't feel right that we check
  correctness of the actual declaration in expect-actual matcher.
- ~~It may change the rules of expect actual matching~~ (It's not true,
  because ActualFunctionWithDefaultParameters is declared as WEAK
  incompatibility)
This commit is contained in:
Nikita Bobko
2023-06-28 16:42:26 +02:00
committed by teamcity
parent ab8913dee8
commit d39755b578
41 changed files with 450 additions and 59 deletions
@@ -376,6 +376,22 @@ object AbstractExpectActualCompatibilityChecker {
}
}
if (shouldCheckAbsenceOfDefaultParamsInActual) {
// "Default parameters in actual" check is required only for functions, because only functions can have parameters
if (actualDeclaration is FunctionSymbolMarker && expectDeclaration is FunctionSymbolMarker) {
// Actual annotation constructors can have default argument values; their consistency with arguments in the expected annotation
// is checked in ExpectedActualDeclarationChecker.checkAnnotationConstructors
if (!actualDeclaration.isAnnotationConstructor() &&
// If default params came from common supertypes of actual class and expect class then it's a valid code.
// Here we filter out such default params.
(actualDeclaration.allOverriddenDeclarationsRecursive() - expectDeclaration.allOverriddenDeclarationsRecursive().toSet())
.flatMap { it.valueParameters }.any { it.hasDefaultValue }
) {
return Incompatible.ActualFunctionWithDefaultParameters
}
}
}
if (!equalsBy(expectedValueParameters, actualValueParameters) { it.isVararg }) {
return Incompatible.ValueParameterVararg
}
@@ -39,6 +39,9 @@ interface ExpectActualMatchingContext<T : DeclarationSymbolMarker> : TypeSystemC
val enumConstructorsAreAlwaysCompatible: Boolean
get() = false
// Try to drop it once KT-61105 is fixed
val shouldCheckAbsenceOfDefaultParamsInActual: Boolean
/**
* This flag determines, how visibilities for classes/typealiases will be matched
* - `false` means that visibilities should be identical
@@ -115,6 +118,11 @@ interface ExpectActualMatchingContext<T : DeclarationSymbolMarker> : TypeSystemC
val CallableSymbolMarker.typeParameters: List<TypeParameterSymbolMarker>
val FunctionSymbolMarker.valueParameters: List<ValueParameterSymbolMarker>
/**
* Returns all symbols that are overridden by [this] symbol
*/
fun FunctionSymbolMarker.allOverriddenDeclarationsRecursive(): Sequence<CallableSymbolMarker>
val CallableSymbolMarker.valueParameters: List<ValueParameterSymbolMarker>
get() = (this as? FunctionSymbolMarker)?.valueParameters ?: emptyList()